UK forced to admit secret Apple encryption order

Original: UK government forced to admit it issued Apple a secret encryption order

Why This Matters

Sets a precedent limiting governments' ability to hide surveillance orders from public scrutiny.

The UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled the government must acknowledge it issued Apple a Technical Capability Notice under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, ending months of official denial about the secret encryption order.

The UK government has been compelled to publicly admit it issued Apple a Technical Capability Notice (TCN) — a secret order under Section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 — after the Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected its attempt to maintain complete secrecy about the order's existence.

The story began in February 2025, when the Washington Post reported that the UK had ordered Apple to provide backdoor access to encrypted iCloud data belonging not just to UK users, but potentially Apple customers worldwide. Rather than comply, Apple pulled its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature — which extends end-to-end encryption to additional iCloud data categories — from new UK users entirely.

The original notice was eventually withdrawn following diplomatic pressure involving the Trump administration. The UK then issued a second TCN, reportedly scoped only to British users, prompting Apple to file a fresh legal challenge in 2026.

Despite the original order having been widely reported by multiple outlets, the government maintained its official position of neither confirming nor denying individual TCNs. At a September 17 hearing, barristers for civil liberties groups Liberty and Privacy International challenged that stance. Ben Jaffey KC compared the government's secrecy posture to the 'emperor's new clothes.' The Tribunal agreed — ruling the government must now formally acknowledge the notice exists. The full content of the order remains secret.

Source

macanorak.com — Read original →