Quad9 Exits France Over DNS Piracy Blocking Orders

Original: Quad9 Is Leaving France: Why DNS Resolvers Are the Wrong Place to Fight Piracy

Why This Matters

Sets a precedent that could push other public resolvers out of EU jurisdictions.

Quad9, the Swiss non-profit running the 9.9.9.9 DNS resolver, will stop serving French users on November 24, 2026, after a Paris court fined it for refusing to block pirate sports-streaming domains for beIN Sports.

On November 24, 2026, Quad9 will shut off DNS resolution for all French IP addresses. The move follows a Paris court ruling that found the non-profit liable for refusing to enforce blocking orders under Article L.333-10 of the French sports code — legislation originally passed in 2021 that lets rightsholders obtain 'dynamic' blocking orders against 'any person able to help stop the infringement.' That phrase is broad enough to cover public DNS resolvers.

With around 20 similar cases still pending in France, Quad9 concluded that compliance would undermine its core mission — it blocks malware and phishing domains, not piracy lists — and that continued litigation was financially unsustainable for a small non-profit.

The collateral damage is significant. Quad9's own traffic data shows French networks including DINUM, Institut Pasteur, SNCF, EDF, AP-HM hospitals, and Airbus subsidiary Stormshield all rely on its resolver. Because Quad9 retains no user data by design, it cannot directly notify any of them. Cloudflare, which runs the competing 1.1.1.1 service, warned that when a resolver disappears without notice, 'their Internet will simply stop working.'

Cloudflare called the situation 'a canary in the coal mine.' Quad9 CTO John Todd took to Hacker News to ask the technical community to write detailed, sourced arguments explaining why targeting DNS resolvers is the wrong policy approach, and to send them to French policymakers. France's Parliament further amended L.333-10 in July 2026, potentially widening the scope further.

Source

techstackups.com — Read original →